What happens next

What happens after you add an item

Submitted, In review, Verified or Needs info.

  1. Submitted: your item is in our review line. Nothing else for you to do.
  2. In review: a Choice team member looks at your photos and details and, for graded items, compares the cert number with the grader's public lookup (PCGS, NGC, CBCS, PSA and others).
  3. Verified: we've checked what we can and may add published details to your item, such as corrected/verified details, the cert check result, or extra info. You'll see them on the item page.
  4. Needs info: we'll tell you exactly what we need (usually a clearer label photo or the cert number). Edit the item and it goes back to Submitted on its own.

Good to know:

  • If you later change the identifying details or photos of a Verified item, it goes back to Submitted so we can re-check it.
  • Verification means we checked the details and the cert record. It is not an appraisal, an authentication guarantee, or an offer to buy.
  • Want to sell, consign, grade, or get help building your collection? Request a consultation and we'll reply by email.
  • Review timing varies; we don't promise a turnaround time.