Collectors helping collectors
Choice Custom Collections LLC is a new, hands-on collectibles business in Lantana, Florida, owned and run by Jay.
Meaningful, trustworthy, beautifully presented
Our mission is to turn collectibles into meaningful, trustworthy, beautifully presented collections, helping collectors build what they love and helping people and businesses give gifts that are remembered.
We buy and sell coins, trading cards, comics, and autographs. Our signature offering is the custom collection: a themed, presentation-ready set built for a specific person, team, brand, or occasion. Consignment, appraisals, grading help, and estate buying round out what we do.
You'll find us online, at South Florida shows, live on Whatnot, and on eBay.
Placeholder: Jay's personal story, collecting background, specialties, and photo go here. eBay and Whatnot links will be added once the store pages are live.
What we stand for
- Authenticity first. Nothing is sold without a clear basis for authenticity: a third-party grade or certification, or documented provenance.
- Fair dealing. Transparent buy offers that show the comps they're based on.
- Curation over clutter. Every collection tells a story.
- Service. Fast replies, safe shipping, and easy follow-up.
The go-to source for authentic, curated collectibles
Known for honest pricing, verified authenticity, and presentation quality, in South Florida and online.
Coins
Morgan & Peace dollars, 90% silver, key dates, certified coins, and 2026 Semiquincentennial sets.
Trading Cards
Graded rookies of established stars, vintage cards, and graded Pokémon & TCG.
Comics
True keys and first appearances, CGC-graded and raw.
Autographs
Certified only: PSA/DNA, JSA, or Beckett authenticated.
Ready to talk about your collection?
Buying, selling, or just curious what you have: start with a message.